Fintechs fail to make a dent in Mexico as cash remains king

Cash still drives 90% of transactions under 500 Mexican pesos ($25), as well as 78.7% of payments or bills over 500 pesos

In Mexico, fintechs struggle as cash is still king
Mexican peso banknotes. Photo: REUTERS/Jose Luis Gonzalez

Financial inclusion levels in Mexico have worsened since 2018, official statistics show, despite a burst of financial startups hoping to ‘bank the unbanked’.

Mexicans with at least one financial product last year fell 0.5% to 67.8% compared with 2018, the National Inclusion Report (ENIF) concluded this month. Meanwhile, cash still drives 90% of transactions under 500 Mexican pesos ($25), as well as 78.7% of payments or bills over 500 pesos.

That puts Latin America‘s second-most populous country far behind similar economies like India, Kenya and Brazil in terms of inclusion and its reliance on cash.

This comes despite hundreds of ‘pro-inclusion’ fintechs arriving in Mexico since 2016, offering easier ways to sign up or no-fee banking, including Klar, Keusiki Pay, Stori, and Albo.

While attracting millions of users, these startups are struggling to move the needle around Mexico‘s informal economy, says Maelis Carraro, managing director at consulting firm BFA Global.

Fintech innovators have not yet delivered on their potential to build solutions that are centered on underserved communities,” she told Reuters, adding that fintechs mostly target Latin America‘s metropolitan elite, rather than poorer, rural communities where banking infrastructure is most needed.

For their part, fintechs say they need more regulatory support to have impact.

READ ALSO: Latin America had its fourth-largest quarter in startup investments to date, according to LAVCA. But what lies ahead?

“Until more digital players become [licensed as] banks, inclusion will continue to hit a ceiling,” said Juan Guerra, Revolut‘s Mexico chief executive.

Fintech users still need to link their digital accounts to licensed banks, requiring a visit to traditional brick-and-mortar branches, he said.

Since the government introduced its ‘fintech law’ in 2018, 58 companies have been approved or provisionally approved for payment licenses, according to the Mexican Fintech Association, yet no new retail banking licenses have been issued.

READ ALSO: Fintechs in Brazil are leveraging their operations with this type of fixed-income fund

At the same time, the proportion of Mexican adults with bank accounts edged up two percentage points between 2018 and 2021 to 49.1%, while card usage for larger transactions increased to a modest 12.3%.

Mexico, meanwhile, continues to attract international startups like Nubank, Uala and Revolut, with ambitious full-scale banking plans.

Convenience-store Oxxo also launched a banking app last November, and says it already boasts 1.6 million users. Customers can sign up directly in Oxxo stores, which are far more populous nationwide than bank branches.

The Mexican government has separately undertaken a pilot project to get women banked, after the gender gap for financial inclusion doubled to 12% in 2021.

Officials are also beginning to dispense welfare benefits via digital wallets or bank deposits, rather than cash, as well as encouraging the adoption of the government mobile payments system CoDi, launched in 2019.

Get the best insights about Latin America market in your inbox